I appreciate what you're trying to do here, and I share your commitment to combating anti-Muslim bigotry. But several of your historical claims are just flagrantly false. The Constitution of Medina did not establish separation of religion and state; Muhammad exercised both religious and political authority. Classical Islamic jurisprudence explicitly prescribed punishments for apostasy and adultery, so claiming these are "categorically condemned in Islamic teaching" is simply false. And Muhammad certainly did not guarantee unrestricted freedom of pagan worship after conquering Mecca since he ordered the destruction of the idols in the Kaaba. You can make a compelling case for a liberal, pluralistic interpretation of Islam without misrepresenting its history or presenting your particular theological interpretation as universally accepted fact.
Well done. Not every "law" is the government's law -- there are shariahs, and the laws of physics, and supply and demand. You could strengthen your argument by referring to the Canon law of the Roman Catholic church. That's also a shariah, that applies only to those who voluntarily accept it, and governs the internal affairs of the religious community. Bahai law is the same, tho' not so well known. Bahais also get the reaction of "law" + "religion" = theocracy.
Really appreciate all the learning not only in this piece but in all the linked articles also. It's vital for us all to educate ourselves, and I am truly thankful for every bit of historical context you share here. Question for future exploration, if you feel called to taking that on: what is your take on Muslim conquest throughout history?
When I was teaching world religion courses, I described Shari'a as more of a process. There is no one written Shari'a. The five different schools of Shari'a don't always agree. Within each school there are many scholars in the ulama who debate various aspects of Shari'a.
I'd add that throughout most of Muslim history the separation of religion and state was probably the only form of Islamic government. Much of Shari'a scholarship was written in usually futile efforts to convince Muslim rulers to be more Islamic in their rule. There were laws of state and religious Shari'a.
My master's dissertation, "Church and State," was completed after 9/11, which led me to add a big section on church and state in Islamic origins and history. Yes, almost all over the Islamic history and geography, two laws and two orders prevailed -- "church and state" in western terms. The exceptions are contemporary Iran and the Mahdi state. Theocracy is un-Islamic.
I forgot to add that Western colonialism produced the reactions that led towards movements within Islam to make Shari'a the law of the land. The first groups to advocate for Shari'a as theocracy were Muslim intellectuals opposing colonial rule.
Yes, but it goes back a bit further and wider than politically effective colonisation of Muslim-majority territories: Islamism is a polemic reaction to euro-centric claims to superiority and therefore hegemony. The subaltern says, "if Europeans say that their separation of church and state makes us inferior, if they say [in their ignorance and prejudice] that Islam does not know the separation of church and state, then we will take that as a badge of pride." As Ali Abdel Raziq (Islam and the Foundations of Political Power) showed, this was the uncritical adoption by Muslims of what Europeans were saying about Islam. They should have known better, as both Quran and history show
I am forever grateful for this opportunity to learn and understand. You've taken something feared because it is unknown - and presented it as being simple and beautiful. I look forward to more.
Qasim, merci beaucoup for the explanation of Sharia law, aka Shakira law to the rubes. Oh, that the rubes would READ this, but we are well aware of their delight in their ignorance. I love that the meaning points the way to living waters, as does the Xian Bible. Thanks to your explanation, I see the beauty in your religious faith. Again, Merci!
This is an amazing breakdown and explanation of so-called (erroneously) "Sharia Law".
I believe this should be required reading for all American citizens before they are allowed to vote in today's political environs.
It should be taught—oh, wait—in whatever we now call the "education system" in this country or what's left of it?
My Wife, Brenda, is a TikTok Creator who does Live political debates. She hears this topic thrown up (literally?) by blissfully ignorant—willfully ignorant—MAGA and religious people.
I have family in my old FB (barely go there anymore as I am too busy writing my Substack articles) who claim to be devout Christians... and they bring this up all the time.
I argue this with my own family as Brenda does with her "guests" in her TikTok work.
Honestly, I wish I could do more to end this. Not just the Fascist rule (I’ve never missed a vote) but the cultural/ethical change needed to stop terrorizing people of color and different faiths, and of no religious beliefs. It really is important to include the atheist/irreligious groups who are also excluded and discriminated against. We are a secular nation for the very purpose of allowing all faiths and none-at-all to be part of the colorful weave of our country. The Nationalists, racists, Fascists want a milk white christian world that they can no longer have!
I hope you will look at Captain Ibrahim Traore in Burkina Faso and explain why it is that he needs to put so much effort and resources into restraining the Muslims in his country who are working against the well-being of the population. even though he himself is a practicing Muslim.
I just looked at your substack because a long time ago I believe you were a candidate for office in Virginia? and I recognized your name. I was referred to you by my current State Representative for help with a problem with a juvenile detention program. I never did contact you about that. kind of irrelevant here, but you got a good word as a just and caring person.
OTOH, I am not totally buying your take on Islam in the present day. I find Captain Traore of Burkina Faso an inspirational Muslim figure. unfortunately, he is in position where he is battling Western sponsored insurgents who claim to be fighting jihad. He is struggling to develop a secular society that serves the needs of his people, and unfortunately is battling Muslim extremists on the homefront in this effort. there is endless discussion about what Islam really does or does not prescribe, but what is happening on the ground tells you how it can be used, and why it is opposed in some places.
I didn’t grow up with much religion. My father was a doctor who didn’t believe in any form of Christian religion. My mother occasionally took us kids to a small Episcopal church in a small nearby town. The priest, who everybody called Jack, was a wonderful man. When I was a child and asked him questions, he answered them honestly. When he left, that was the end for me, for a long time.
I doubt if either of my parents knew about Shariah. We didn’t fear it because we didn’t know about it. All that to say as an adult of course I heard about it and knew enough not to be fearful. And the people who feared it were mostly right wing or very uneducated. So I rejected their hate and fear. I really appreciated you educating us. I learn a lot from your columns - this one particularly resonated to me. At 83 I’m still learning and I love it. Thank you.
No, they're an example of weak insecure and uneducated men who are using religion as an excuse to oppress. It's the male patriarchy that's the issue. Islamic shariah opposes their entire existence.
I appreciate what you're trying to do here, and I share your commitment to combating anti-Muslim bigotry. But several of your historical claims are just flagrantly false. The Constitution of Medina did not establish separation of religion and state; Muhammad exercised both religious and political authority. Classical Islamic jurisprudence explicitly prescribed punishments for apostasy and adultery, so claiming these are "categorically condemned in Islamic teaching" is simply false. And Muhammad certainly did not guarantee unrestricted freedom of pagan worship after conquering Mecca since he ordered the destruction of the idols in the Kaaba. You can make a compelling case for a liberal, pluralistic interpretation of Islam without misrepresenting its history or presenting your particular theological interpretation as universally accepted fact.
Well done. Not every "law" is the government's law -- there are shariahs, and the laws of physics, and supply and demand. You could strengthen your argument by referring to the Canon law of the Roman Catholic church. That's also a shariah, that applies only to those who voluntarily accept it, and governs the internal affairs of the religious community. Bahai law is the same, tho' not so well known. Bahais also get the reaction of "law" + "religion" = theocracy.
Thank you for this and I will read the long version as well!
Really appreciate all the learning not only in this piece but in all the linked articles also. It's vital for us all to educate ourselves, and I am truly thankful for every bit of historical context you share here. Question for future exploration, if you feel called to taking that on: what is your take on Muslim conquest throughout history?
Thank you for this. Very well done. I enjoyed reading and learning.
Did any pick up that the person in question called it Shakira law? ffs
When I was teaching world religion courses, I described Shari'a as more of a process. There is no one written Shari'a. The five different schools of Shari'a don't always agree. Within each school there are many scholars in the ulama who debate various aspects of Shari'a.
I'd add that throughout most of Muslim history the separation of religion and state was probably the only form of Islamic government. Much of Shari'a scholarship was written in usually futile efforts to convince Muslim rulers to be more Islamic in their rule. There were laws of state and religious Shari'a.
My master's dissertation, "Church and State," was completed after 9/11, which led me to add a big section on church and state in Islamic origins and history. Yes, almost all over the Islamic history and geography, two laws and two orders prevailed -- "church and state" in western terms. The exceptions are contemporary Iran and the Mahdi state. Theocracy is un-Islamic.
I forgot to add that Western colonialism produced the reactions that led towards movements within Islam to make Shari'a the law of the land. The first groups to advocate for Shari'a as theocracy were Muslim intellectuals opposing colonial rule.
Yes, but it goes back a bit further and wider than politically effective colonisation of Muslim-majority territories: Islamism is a polemic reaction to euro-centric claims to superiority and therefore hegemony. The subaltern says, "if Europeans say that their separation of church and state makes us inferior, if they say [in their ignorance and prejudice] that Islam does not know the separation of church and state, then we will take that as a badge of pride." As Ali Abdel Raziq (Islam and the Foundations of Political Power) showed, this was the uncritical adoption by Muslims of what Europeans were saying about Islam. They should have known better, as both Quran and history show
“That said, I hope you have a pleasant Father’s Day” is the weirdest tone shift lol
Great article, as always! ❤️ Thank you for all you do and for countering Islamophobic disinformation about Sharia Law!!
I am forever grateful for this opportunity to learn and understand. You've taken something feared because it is unknown - and presented it as being simple and beautiful. I look forward to more.
Qasim, merci beaucoup for the explanation of Sharia law, aka Shakira law to the rubes. Oh, that the rubes would READ this, but we are well aware of their delight in their ignorance. I love that the meaning points the way to living waters, as does the Xian Bible. Thanks to your explanation, I see the beauty in your religious faith. Again, Merci!
This is an amazing breakdown and explanation of so-called (erroneously) "Sharia Law".
I believe this should be required reading for all American citizens before they are allowed to vote in today's political environs.
It should be taught—oh, wait—in whatever we now call the "education system" in this country or what's left of it?
My Wife, Brenda, is a TikTok Creator who does Live political debates. She hears this topic thrown up (literally?) by blissfully ignorant—willfully ignorant—MAGA and religious people.
I have family in my old FB (barely go there anymore as I am too busy writing my Substack articles) who claim to be devout Christians... and they bring this up all the time.
I argue this with my own family as Brenda does with her "guests" in her TikTok work.
Honestly, I wish I could do more to end this. Not just the Fascist rule (I’ve never missed a vote) but the cultural/ethical change needed to stop terrorizing people of color and different faiths, and of no religious beliefs. It really is important to include the atheist/irreligious groups who are also excluded and discriminated against. We are a secular nation for the very purpose of allowing all faiths and none-at-all to be part of the colorful weave of our country. The Nationalists, racists, Fascists want a milk white christian world that they can no longer have!
I hope you will look at Captain Ibrahim Traore in Burkina Faso and explain why it is that he needs to put so much effort and resources into restraining the Muslims in his country who are working against the well-being of the population. even though he himself is a practicing Muslim.
I just looked at your substack because a long time ago I believe you were a candidate for office in Virginia? and I recognized your name. I was referred to you by my current State Representative for help with a problem with a juvenile detention program. I never did contact you about that. kind of irrelevant here, but you got a good word as a just and caring person.
OTOH, I am not totally buying your take on Islam in the present day. I find Captain Traore of Burkina Faso an inspirational Muslim figure. unfortunately, he is in position where he is battling Western sponsored insurgents who claim to be fighting jihad. He is struggling to develop a secular society that serves the needs of his people, and unfortunately is battling Muslim extremists on the homefront in this effort. there is endless discussion about what Islam really does or does not prescribe, but what is happening on the ground tells you how it can be used, and why it is opposed in some places.
I didn’t grow up with much religion. My father was a doctor who didn’t believe in any form of Christian religion. My mother occasionally took us kids to a small Episcopal church in a small nearby town. The priest, who everybody called Jack, was a wonderful man. When I was a child and asked him questions, he answered them honestly. When he left, that was the end for me, for a long time.
I doubt if either of my parents knew about Shariah. We didn’t fear it because we didn’t know about it. All that to say as an adult of course I heard about it and knew enough not to be fearful. And the people who feared it were mostly right wing or very uneducated. So I rejected their hate and fear. I really appreciated you educating us. I learn a lot from your columns - this one particularly resonated to me. At 83 I’m still learning and I love it. Thank you.
This is extremely informative, thank you. If you see this, I have a question. Is what the Taliban in Afghanistan just an extreme form of Sharia law?
No, they're an example of weak insecure and uneducated men who are using religion as an excuse to oppress. It's the male patriarchy that's the issue. Islamic shariah opposes their entire existence.
Thank you. I thought that was the case but wasn't sure.