Three Lessons 23 Years After 9/11
As we mourn and reflect on the past, three key lessons to ensure we do right by the future
On 9/11/01, I was a 19-year-old college sophomore. I am among the last generations who was an adult prior to 9/11, and observed the changes our world and country went through since. With that context, I need to make three important points today.
Let’s Address This.
Lesson 1: Perspective in mourning
On 9/11 we mourn 2977 fellow Americans. Innocent people viciously ripped away from us by terrorists and extremists. We pray for the 2977 departed, we remember them, and we cherish their memories. And too often the conversation stops there. But there is so much more we must remember.
In the 23 years since we lost roughly 10,000 American soldiers. Depending on various estimates, hundreds of thousands of Afghan and Iraq civilians were killed in the two subsequent wars after 9/11. Our government wasted more than $8 Trillion on the "war on terror"—a shocking $250 million a day for more than two decades. And we are no safer or closer to peace or justice today, than we were back then.
In the days and weeks after 9/11, Rep Barbara Lee stood with moral courage to oppose the war, and she was right. History has tragically proven her more right than I believe even she might have imagined. After 23 long, painful years, my prayer is that our future policies are not built on invasion and war, but on justice and diplomacy, on accountability and transparency. On our Constitutional promise of due process and human rights.
Lesson 2: Perspective in history
Uninformed memes like the one below have begun popping up over the last few years, dangerously whitewashing post 9/11 America by falsely calling us a "unified" country on 9/12.
If even after 23 years you think the weeks or months after 9/11 were days of unity, you have not been paying attention to the BIPOC people and Muslims in America. The people in your life who feared for our safety and suffered a massive spike in hate crimes for something we had nothing to do with.
Yes, the myth of "unity" means ignoring the massive spike in anti-Muslim, anti-Hindu, anti-Sikh, and anti-Arab hate crimes post 9/11. It means ignoring the Patriot Act (which even some Democrats in Congress still recklessly vote for), the NYPD’s illegal warrantless spying on American citizens who are Muslim, the dozens of states who tried to pass "anti-Shariah" bills, Guantanamo Bay, CIA torture, indiscriminate drone strikes, & the Muslim Ban—all which denied the justice our Constitution promises.
These are all connected.
The "unity" was if you unquestionably supported what George W. Bush called "a crusade," that “God told him” to wage. Otherwise, you were unpatriotic. "You're either with us, or you're with the terrorists," Bush famously said—whitewashing objections to killing of hundreds of thousands of Afghan and Iraqi civilians
Instead, the unity we actually need is unity built on justice, as our Constitution requires. On ensuring we do not scapegoat innocent people, but always uphold due process for all people—especially when it's hard.
If we can't uphold justice when it's hard, it was never justice we upheld.
Lesson 3: Perspective on the future
Revisionist history of "unity" undermines the lived experiences of BIPOC people and Muslims. Let's instead reflect on our past errors, and ensure a future nation built on justice. The reality is that anti-Muslim hate crimes are still at record highs. Donald Trump has promised an even more aggressive anti-Muslim ban if he’s reelected. And it is unsurprising that Trump promises more Islamophobic bigotry, given that Islamophobia remains an acceptable form of bigotry in American politics today.
And as I’ve written recently, even the Department of Justice tragically demonstrates a double standard in how they respond to the murder and kidnapping of American citizens—condemning and prosecuting crimes committed by Hamas, but ignoring those crimes against American citizens committed by Netanyahu.
The future also requires we do right by those who continue to suffer from 9/11 in the United States. How many people realize that more FDNY members have died from World Trade Center illnesses than killed on 9/11? Our nation’s lack of guaranteed universal healthcare as a human right is a perpetual atrocity inflicted upon our populace.
If we want to ensure we learn from the lessons of history, our future must be grounded in absolute justice. That means rejecting double standards in legal accountability, rejecting discriminatory legislation against marginalized communities, and rejecting anti-Muslim bigotry and Islamophobia. Today we mourn those lost over the last 23 years. The people lost, the opportunities lost, and the rights lost. And the best way to honor what we lost, is to ensure we truly uphold justice for the next 23 years, and beyond, to demand true justice for all. True love of humanity requires it. Just remember, love isn't a word, it's meaningful action for justice. And that is something we must Never Forget
Why Your Support Matters: Every dollar we spend is a vote for the kind of future we want. Help me create a future more committed to justice and universal human rights. Subscribe, and I welcome your thoughts, feedback, and insights. Thank you.
excellent points...I just wish more Americans were on board with this. I am disappointed that Kamala has watered down her previous stated values for the sake of a win...the debate revealed her diluted stance on Palestinians, gun control, fracking/oil production (and their consequential negative effect on our environment) and universal healthcare. These changes are driven by voter consensus vs. conviction of what is right or what ultimately best promotes equality, justice or the care of our environment . I understand that in order to win, this is what she has to do. Because unfortunately, the Americans are too short sighted and selfish to be on board with the bigger picture. But, I am hoping she can influence our country towards these more lofty goals. I know for a fact, with her, at least we have the possibility of heading in the right direction, which would never happen under Fascist Trump and his autocratic Republicans.
I have to say Qasim mirrors my thoughts each day, but the way he puts it in words is so much better than what I would Have used. I get too angry! In contrast, Qasim’s words are based with truth, reason and love. Thank you so much, Qasim!