Israeli PM Netanyahu to Address Congress on July 26
What to expect as American leadership proudly welcomes a man credibly accused of war crimes
It’s official. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will address a joint session of U.S. Congress on June 26. Below is the letter bearing the signatures of all four Congressional leaders who formally invited him last week.
This will be Netanyahu’s fourth address to a joint session of Congress (1996, 2011, 2015). And while there have been more than 100 such joint sessions addressed by foreign leaders, you’d be hard pressed to find an invitation to an accused war criminal like Benjamin Netanyahu.
Here’s what to expect as American leadership proudly invites a man credibly accused of war crimes. Prime Minister Netanyahu will spend his remarks undermining peace and justice by spewing misinformation and disinformation about his policies and the Palestinian people. Netanyahu’s lies will span at least five areas.
1. Lies about the origins of this siege on Gaza
Netanyahu will claim all was well on 10/6, and Hamas attacked Israel without warning or cause—other than their hatred of Jewish people. As I’ve written before, we cannot understand 10/7 unless we first recognize the ground reality leading up to 10/7. Netanyahu will ignore those ground realities.
For example, Netanyahu will ignore Israel’s 57 year illegal military occupation of Palestinian territories for the illegal act it is. He will ignore that Hamas is not an ancient organization, but having been established only in 1987, it is a reaction to more than then 20 years of illegal occupation and land grab. And he will ignore Israel’s 700,000 illegal settlements as the violation of international human rights law that they are, as repeatedly affirmed by the United Nations and the United States.
Netanyahu will also ignore that two decades of Israel’s land, air, and sea blockades on Gaza left people desperate and distressed, and violates international human rights law. He will ignore that some 9500 Palestinians are indefinitely detained in Israeli prison in what is known as administrative detention, many without charge or opportunity for release. And he will ignore that as you read this, up to 1000 Palestinian children are indefinitely detained in Israeli prison, again without charge, under so-called administrative detention.
Likewise, Netanyahu will ignore that in the year prior to 10/7 the Israeli military killed at least 240 Palestinian civilians in the West Bank—a death toll that included 47 children—and in fact was the deadliest year in recent history for Palestinian civilians.
Finally, Netanyahu will ignore that he deliberately propped up Hamas for years with the specific goal to undermine Palestinian statehood, regional security, and empowerment of the people of Palestine.
In short, Netanyahu will attempt to paint Hamas’ war crime attack on civilians on 10/7 as a spontaneous attack out of the blue—without any of the above history of Israeli war crimes. Don’t let him get away with that false narrative.
2. Lies about his policies during this siege on Gaza
Netanyahu will claim Israel is the “most moral Army in the world,” and will lie about his policies in Gaza. He will ignore South Africa’s documented ICJ lawsuit accusing Israel of genocide, proving intent with the very words of Israeli leadership seeking full and total destruction of Gaza and replacement of Palestinians. He will ignore the ICC’s detailed accusations against him and his Defense Minister, Gallant, for indiscriminately bombing civilians in Palestine. He will ignore that the New York Times and NBC have documented more than 200 instances where the Israeli military forced Palestinians into a confirmed “safe zone,” only to bomb that very safe zone, killing thousands of innocent civilians. And he will attempt to make the bombings of civilians, journalists, aid workers, and children seem like they were honest mistakes.
They were not honest mistakes. They were deliberate war crimes, and it is critical we do not fall for this continued gaslighting.
3. Lies about the International Criminal Court (ICC)
Netanyahu will claim the ICC is making an equivalence between Israel and Hamas—a meritless claim the ICC has already thoroughly debunked. But meanwhile, Netanyahu will ignore that Israel has illegally spied on the ICC for the past nine years, and aggressively attempted to bribe and intimidate the previous and current ICC Prosecutor. Netanyahu will claim the ICC has no jurisdiction over Israel, ignoring that Palestine has been a member state of the ICC since April 1, 2015. Therefore, the ICC has jurisdiction over war crimes committed in Palestine—which Israel has committed.
The ICC, like the ICJ, is working in accordance with the rules of international human rights law, and their authority must be respected if we truly claim “no one is above the law.”
4. Lies about how this conflict can be resolved
Netanyahu will claim “all that needs to happen for this war to end is for Hamas to release the hostages.” But we know this is false, as even the current offer President Biden announced is one Netanyahu himself rejected less than an hour later—specifically because Netanyahu wants to continue to bomb Gaza indiscriminately.
CNN likewise reported, "Less than an hour after Biden detailed the Israeli proposal, Netanyahu’s office insisted Israel would not end the war until Hamas is defeated and “all its goals are achieved.” Moreover, the very families of hostages are now openly accusing Netanyahu of giving up on the hostages, unless it can benefit him personally. “Netanyahu won’t agree to hostage release deal unless it polls well for him, Israeli families say they were told, adding, “The Israeli government made a conscious and deliberate decision to sacrifice the hostages,” the Hostage Family Forum said.”
This conflict will truly resolve with a permanent and lasting ceasefire, an unconditional release of all hostages from both sides, an end to Israel’s military occupation of Palestine, an end to Israel’s illegal settlements in Palestine, an end to Israel’s illegal blockade of Gaza, a sovereign Palestinian state, a prosecution of all war crimes in front of the ICC, and a rebuilding of Gaza and the West Bank.
5. Lies about his critics
Netanyahu will likely lean heavily into claiming criticism of him, of the Israeli government, and of how Israel has conducted its bombing of Gaza is all rooted in antisemitism. While antisemitism must never be tolerated, condemning war crimes is not antisemitism—it is pro justice. Incidentally, on a recent hike in rural Colorado I came across this sticker at a rest stop.
It should shock the conscience that in addition to banning journalists altogether, the Israeli government has killed more than 108 journalists and media workers reporting from inside Gaza. Indeed, it is no wonder that numerous Jewish organizations are loudly condemning Netanyahu’s injustices, rejecting the claims of antisemitism, and demanding justice for Palestine.
In conclusion, this is not an exhaustive list, but I’d be surprised if Netanyahu does not at least touch on all five of these at some point, among others, during his June 13th address. It is a shame that American political leadership has made a bipartisan commitment to invite a credibly accused war criminal to address a joint session of Congress. Doing so does nothing to benefit the American people, further harms Palestinians, and does not make Israel any safer. One thing is for sure, however, that this invitation has emphatically debunked the claim that the United States is committed to an international rules based order.
And that reality is devastating for the prospect of international peace and justice.
EDIT: After the publication of this piece, Congress announced Netanyahu’s address will be July 26, not June 13. This piece has been updated accordingly.
The extent to which the West consciously continues to distort history and get away with it is mind boggling. The original lie was to themselves. Rather than taking responsibility for the deep rooted anti-Semitism that was pervasive throughout Europe and its settler colonies in North America, Australia etc. for centuries, they absolved themselves by making Germany the only focal point anti-Jewish prejudice and Palestinians the whipping boy when the latter had absolutely nothing to do with the tragic plight of European Jewry. Worse yet, is the long history of relatively peaceful coexistence between Jewish and Muslim communities across West Asia and North Africa got shattered as a result of the establishment of Israel - because the only way it was possible to create a Jewish majority state on a land that was 95 percent Palestinian Arab in 1914 and 70 percent Palestinian Arab in 1947 was to drive them out. As Benny Morris (Israel's historian in chief and himself and ardent, arguably rabid, Zionist) puts it, "the idea of transfer (the euphemism Zionists use for ethnic cleansing) is as old as modern Zionism and has accompanied its evolution and praxis during the past century."
Within the academy, there isn't any serious dispute surrounding the facts. Israel has consistently acted belligerently (to put it mildly) since it's inception - just like any other settler colonial project engaging in drastic social engineering would have to. But the West was and continues to be perfectly content to peddle lies to avoid having to engage in any serious introspection. It's a testament to just how alive and well the colonist, imperialist mindset remains in 2024.
While the US and Canada may talk at great lengths of how horrific and tragic the consequences of anti-Semitism was (and there's absolutely no doubt about it), they were perfectly happy to admit tens of not hundreds of thousands of ex-Nazis into their countries, and in Canada's case (and probably the US' too) continuing to restrict Jewish immigration till well into the 1960s (see: https://time.com/6322156/history-of-nazi-immigration/ and; https://thetyee.ca/Analysis/2023/10/13/Canada-Let-Thousands-Former-Nazis/).
So all this talk about caring about the plight of the Jewish people that we keep hearing from Western elites is largely smoke and mirrors. But given that there's no political will to take responsibility for the mess that they've created, I guess the show must go on (standing ovations and everything).
I wonder if anyone or any group has calculated the cost to the American taxpayer of allowing Netanyahu to address the US congress FOUR times? E.G., , 1+ hours, x 510 (min) individuals+perks , X 4????